人治还是法治+——试析对韩非政治思想的分歧性评价

D].长春:东北师范大学,2006.RuleofManorRuleofLaw———OntheDifferentEvaluationsofHanFei'sPoliticalThoughtsZhANGXiaoyu(DepartmentofMarxism,PLANanjingPoliticalInstitute,Nanjing210003,China)Abstract:bininglaw,skillandpower.Butwhetherheadvocatedruleofmanorlawhasremainedcontroversial:thereexisttwototallydifferentopinionsseparatelyrepresentedbyLIANGQichaoandGUOMoruo.ThegapderivesfromHANFei'sownthoughtswhichinevitablyfallintostructuralconflictsofidealismandrealismwhencon-structingnomocracytheory.HeusedinstrumentalrationalitytocriticizeConfucianidealpoliticalviewsbutheldanoptimisticattitudetowardsthemonarchinreverse.Soit'sunfairtosimplyjudgewhetherHANFeiwasanadvocatorofruleofmanoratrumpeterofdictatorship.Keywords:HANFei;legalist;ruleofman;ruleoflaw(责任编辑王爱玲)57胜利油田党校学报JournalofthePartySchoolofShengliOilfield万方数据